Atmosphere – Cape May Area Restaurants and Dining

410 Bank Street

Exotic New Orleans accented cuisine and seafood in Chef Sing’s signature sauces in a vine-covered 1840 carriage house. “One of America’s Top Restaurants” ZAGAT, “The reason many come to Cape May” NYTimes.

5 West Pub

Enjoy fabulous food and cool cocktails in a casual pub atmosphere! Big screen TVs too!

Andrea Trattoria Italiana

BYOB, Authentic Italian fare, fresh & authentic Ingredients

Beach Creek Oyster Bar and Grille

Award winning contemporary international cuisine intimately served inside amidst copper & wooden decor, or on our waterfront deck.

Beach Plum Farm

Discover the old and open spaces of Beach Plum Farm, our 62-acre working farm tucked away in West Cape May.

Bella Vida Garden Cafe

A charming family friendly neighborhood cafe with lots of home cooking. Soups, salads, fresh seafood & more.

The Blue Pig Tavern at Congress Hall

Signature American fare – nostalgic, simple and fresh – featuring local seafood and produce in a warm, relaxing atmosphere.

Boiler Room

Located underground at Congress Hall, this unique restaurant features fresh brick oven artisan pizza, cold draft beer and live music.

Cape May Grilled Cheese

Eat. Chill. Relax. Grilled Cheese, Fries and Burgers….locally sourced ingredients!

Coastal Blue

Classic American plates with unique, local flavor that only the south Jersey shore can claim.

The Ebbitt Room

The Ebbitt Room’s sophisticated, yet casual vibe, creates the perfect setting for a new Cape May dining tradition.

Elaine’s

Get excited to dine in our restaurant, on the Porch, or in the newly expanded Phinney’s Pub, where our culinary staff works hard to deliver the freshest ingredients and finest cocktail options Cape May has to offer.

Fins Bar & Grille

Fins Bar and Grille on the Washington Street Mall serves lunch, dinner and cocktails daily.

Fish House

Fish House enjoys a stunning natural setting overlooking the legendary Sunset Beach.

Grana BYOB

Grana BYOB is a sixty eight seat dream of our executive chef/owner Carl Messick.

Harpoons on the Bay

“Paradise Found!” Situated directly on the Delaware Bay with sunsets to die for, at Harpoons on the Bay, you’ll have to agree you’ve found paradise! A tropical delight awaits your arrival.

Harry’s Ocean Bar & Grille

The best spot to hang out after the beach is Cape May’s only oceanfront rooftop bar!

Hemingway’s Prime Steaks & Seafood

Ocean Front on Beach Avenue. USDA Prime steak, succulent seafood, stylish surroundings and genuine hospitality

Iccara Italian Bistro

The taste of Italy in the heart of Cape May! Located in the heart of Cape May, NJ, just steps from the Washington Street Mall, Iccara Italian Bistro brings you the fresh, unique flavors of Italy in a charming, welcoming atmosphere.

Jake’s Bar & Grill

Enjoy a diverse menu of seafood, appetizers, salads, entrées, and brick oven pizzas at Jake’s.

La Doña Restaurante Mexicano

Authentic Mexican and specifically Oaxacan cuisine specializing in light and fresh foods that one might find on a beautiful Mexican beach.

The Lobster House

Located overlooking Cape May Harbor, The Lobster House has proudly provided guests a variety of dining experiences for over four generations.

Lucky Bones Backwater Grille

A casual restaurant where the food is made from scratch, the drinks are made well, and the service and atmosphere are warm and fun. This is Lucky Bones Backwater Grille.

Mad Batter Restaurant & Bar

Start the morning with our award-winning breakfasts and come back for lunch and dinner! We are open year-round.

Magnolia Room

Featuring Dot and Lucille’s famous fried chicken, crab cakes, yeast risen rolls, corn pudding, spoon bread and delicious desserts such as blueberry cobbler and lemon meringue pie.

Mario’s of Cape May

Mario’s Pizza and Italian Eatery is a family-run business and more than just a pizza place.

Mayer’s Tavern

A lively bar & restaurant serving local seafood & fresh cocktails!

Ocean 7

Fresh, seasonally sourced ingredients serve as inspiration for creative takes on timeless cuisine.

Oyster Bay

Freshest local seafood, certified Angus beef and a newly designed intimate bar.

Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant

Beautiful ocean view dining. Zagat rated romantic, superbly prepared gourmet American fare.

The Pier House

Discover the Pier House, located in La Mer Beachfront Resort overlooking the water’s edge.

Port Cape May

Port Cape May is excited to officially open its space after extensive renovations for summer 2024.

Primal

Welcome to Primal, an upscale open-fire steak house.

Provence

Redefining upscale dining on the Cape May Peninsula, Provence seduces diners with what can only be described as a beautifully choreographed synergy of food, flavors and techniques, plated with undeniable flair and whimsey.

Quincy’s Original

Fun & Fresh, Fast Casual Dining. Enjoy “harbor side” dining while indulging on some of the tastiest lobster rolls and New England specialties this side of Cape Cod.

Rusty Nail

“The Nail,” as it’s known by the locals, is the famed iconic surfer bar and restaurant that made a name for itself in the ‘70s.

Sapore Italiano

Sapore Italiano is a fine dining restaurant offering the best-quality traditional Italian dishes.

SeaSalt Restaurant

SeaSalt Restaurant offers a truly unique seafood fine dining experience featuring fresh indigenous ingredients paired with handcrafted cocktails and specialty wines in an unforgettable chic beach setting.

Star Beach Bar

The iconic Star Beach Bar will “Light The Way” for beachgoers from Cape May to the Wildwoods to enjoy family fun, food, drinks, and live entertainment right on Diamond Beach.

Stowaways

Located next to the bustling Cape May-Lewes Ferry terminal, we offer a convenient and delightful escape for travelers and locals alike.

Taco Caballito

Discover Taco Caballito Tequileria’s unique take on Craft Tacos, Artisanal Tequila and Handcrafted Margaritas.

Tiki Ten35

This poolside spot offers lighthearted bar menu and frosty cocktails day and night!

Tisha’s

Fine Italian, New-American and Seafood in a tradition of love and passion for food and people.

Uncle Bill’s Pancake House

Breakfast is served all day with over 15 different types of pancakes, waffles, french toast, fabulous omelets, farm fresh eggs and meats. Uncle Bill’s has pet friendly outside dining and an extensive lunch menu too!

Union Park Dining Room

Casual fine dining with an ocean view, front porch, amazing cuisine, and excellent service. Private dining rooms available for larger parties.

Vincenzo’s Little Italy II

Looking for a place to go to enjoy great food and even better conversation? The restaurant at Vincenzo’s Little Italy II in North Cape May, NJ boasts of an atmosphere that is both inviting and friendly.

Washington Inn

Built in 1840, this former Cape May plantation residence is now home to the acclaimed Washington Inn and Wine Bar.